Arts Funding in Wales: What Can We Learn from International Models?

The publication of the Welsh Government's Draft Budget for 2027-28 has reignited debate about the future of arts funding in Wales.

In its response, the Arts Council of Wales warned that a standstill budget represents a real-terms reduction in funding once inflation and increasing operating costs are taken into account. The Council argued that the Welsh arts sector has experienced years of financial pressure and highlighted the significant role that public funding plays in supporting artists, venues, organisations and communities across the country.

The immediate debate centres on funding levels. Yet a broader discussion has also emerged: if Wales wishes to strengthen its cultural sector, should it look to alternative funding models being used elsewhere?

Examples from Ireland, Canada, France and Germany are frequently referenced in public discussion, but these countries often pursue very different cultural objectives. Understanding those differences is essential before drawing conclusions about what might work in Wales.

There Is No Single International Model

A 2026 international review commissioned as part of the independent review of Arts Council England examined funding systems in France, Germany, Canada, the United States and South Korea. Its principal finding was straightforward: there is no universally accepted model for supporting culture. Different countries combine public investment, regional funding, philanthropy, artist support programmes and tax incentives in ways that reflect their own histories, economies and political structures.

Rather than identifying a single blueprint, the review highlights a range of approaches that seek to solve different challenges.

Some focus on sustaining cultural institutions. Others prioritise support for individual artists. Some encourage private philanthropy, while others rely heavily on direct public investment.

For Wales, the question may therefore be less about identifying a country to emulate and more about understanding which challenges need to be addressed.

The Welsh Position

According to the Arts Council of Wales, the proposed settlement for 2027-28 maintains current funding levels at approximately £33.7 million annually. The Council has argued that, in practice, this amounts to a reduction in spending power because of rising costs. It has also noted that up to 90% of the funding it receives from Welsh Government is distributed directly into the sector.

Using a population of approximately 3.16 million people, Arts Council funding equates to around £10.70 per person annually.

That figure provides a useful starting point for comparison with other national arts funding agencies.

Comparing National Arts Funding Bodies

The table below compares the primary arts funding bodies in Wales, Ireland and Canada. These figures should not be interpreted as total cultural expenditure for each nation, but rather as investment distributed through their respective national arts agencies.

Country Population Funding Body Annual Investment Per Person (Local Currency) Approx. Per Person (£ Sterling) Wales 3.16 million Arts Council of Wales £33.7 million £10.70 £10.70 Ireland 5.4 million Arts Council Ireland €140 million €25.90 ~£22 Canada 40.1 million Canada Council for the Arts C$284.2 million C$7.10 ~£4

Sources: Arts Council of Wales funding settlement, Arts Council Ireland funding allocations, Canada Council funding overview.

Viewed through this lens, Ireland's Arts Council funding appears significantly higher on a per-capita basis than that of Wales, while Wales appears to invest more per person through its national arts funding body than the grants distributed by the Canada Council. However, such comparisons should be treated cautiously because they do not capture wider government investment, regional spending, municipal support or other mechanisms that operate alongside these agencies.

Ireland: Supporting Artists Directly

Perhaps the most discussed international example in recent months has been Ireland's Basic Income for the Arts scheme.

Unlike many traditional arts funding programmes, the scheme focuses on individuals rather than organisations. The Irish Government states that its objectives include reducing earnings instability, supporting professional artistic practice, improving wellbeing and helping retain creative talent within the arts sector.

The scheme is not universal. It is limited to professional artists who can demonstrate an active artistic practice based primarily in Ireland. Participants are subject to ongoing auditing requirements and contribute to a continuing research programme designed to evaluate the scheme's effectiveness.

Importantly, Ireland's approach addresses a different challenge from conventional grant funding. Rather than primarily supporting institutions, it seeks to address the often-precarious financial circumstances of individual artists.

For Wales, this raises a legitimate policy question: should future interventions focus on organisations, artists themselves, or a combination of both?

Canada: Building Resilience

Canada offers a different perspective.

The international review highlights Canada's emphasis on resilience, sustainability and long-term organisational health. Alongside grant funding, Canadian policy has supported endowment-building, business development and organisational capacity-building programmes designed to strengthen the long-term financial position of cultural organisations.

Rather than concentrating solely on annual funding rounds, Canada has explored mechanisms that aim to increase financial stability and reduce dependency on short-term funding cycles.

This approach may be particularly relevant at a time when arts organisations across many countries are reporting rising costs and increasing pressure on core finances.

France: Encouraging Philanthropy

France combines substantial public investment with policies designed to stimulate private giving.

The international review highlights the impact of the Aillagon Law, which introduced significant tax incentives for charitable giving. The policy contributed to substantial growth in both individual donations and corporate sponsorship while also encouraging the creation of cultural foundations and endowment funds.

Supporters argue that such measures have successfully diversified funding sources for culture.

Critics, meanwhile, point out that generous tax relief effectively represents another form of public support because part of the cost is borne by taxpayers through reduced tax revenues.

The French example illustrates that increasing private investment often requires public intervention of a different kind.

Germany: Culture as a Regional Responsibility

Germany offers another alternative.

The review found that around 80% of cultural spending is delivered by regional governments and municipalities, reflecting the country's highly decentralised political structure. Total public expenditure on culture was reported at approximately €14.9 billion in 2021.

Germany's model demonstrates that devolved decision-making can play a major role in cultural investment. However, it also illustrates the scale of public commitment and administrative infrastructure required to sustain such a system.

The lesson may not simply be about decentralisation itself, but about the resources necessary to make decentralisation effective.

What Questions Should Wales Be Asking?

The international evidence suggests that debates about arts funding frequently combine several separate questions.

The first concerns funding levels: how much should society invest in culture?

The second concerns distribution: who should make funding decisions and how should resources be allocated?

The third concerns beneficiaries: should public support primarily reach organisations, projects, cultural infrastructure or individual artists?

Finally, there is the question of sustainability. Should future policy focus solely on annual grant support, or should it also consider artist incomes, organisational resilience, philanthropy and long-term investment mechanisms?

Different countries answer these questions in different ways.

Conclusion

The evidence does not suggest that Wales can simply copy a single international model.

Ireland, Canada, France and Germany have all developed systems shaped by their own economic circumstances, cultural priorities and political traditions.

What the evidence does reveal is that successful cultural ecosystems rarely rely on one mechanism alone. Public investment, philanthropy, artist support schemes, organisational development and regional delivery structures often work together rather than in isolation.

For Wales, the challenge may therefore be less about deciding which country to follow and more about determining what outcomes cultural policy should achieve over the next decade.

If the goal is supporting artists, one set of solutions emerges.

If the goal is strengthening organisations, another appears.

If the objective is broadening participation, increasing resilience or attracting private investment, different tools become available.

The debate now facing Wales is not only about how much funding culture receives. Increasingly, it is about how that support is structured, who benefits from it and what kind of cultural future the nation wishes to build.

Next
Next

Protected Funding, Rising Pressures: Can Wales Deliver Its Cultural Ambitions?